skip to Main Content

Where To Sell Yugioh Cards in 2023 (17 Best Places)

This post may contain affiliate links which means that sproutinue.com may make a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only promote products that we love and feel will benefit our readers. Please read our Disclosure Policy for more information.

It may reach a point where you no longer feel the thrill of collecting Yugioh cards. You may also need to upgrade your collection by letting go of some cards.

Rather than letting the cards idle in your home, you can make some cash by selling them.

Do you have a collection of Yugioh cards in your house? You’d be surprised by how much those cards could earn you. 

If you want to make quick cash selling Yugioh cards, this article is for you. This article gives you insight into where to sell Yugioh cards and how to do it.

Read on to understand some of the factors that affect your cards’ prices and tips on determining their value to maximize profit.

Where To Sell Yugioh Cards

Whether you’re looking to make quick cash or start a flipping business, there are plenty of places to sell your Yugioh card collection.

Some of the best places to sell Yugioh cards are online marketplaces allowing you to transact with buyers nationwide.

You can also use local selling websites to avoid the shipping costs of online selling platforms. 

Dive into our list if you want to turn your Yugioh card collection into a good amount of cash.

1. TCG Player 

One of the best places to sell Yugioh cards online is TCG Player. This platform connects you to millions of buyers online and in-store.

TCG Player deals not only in Yugioh cards but also in Pokemon cards, comics, and magic cards.

The selling process is simple. All you have to do is create an account and list your cards. You’ll need to set your price and wait for interested buyers to contact you.   

Listing items on the platform is free. Another perk is that TCG Player has a pricing database that helps you determine the price for your cards.

The platform charges a 10.25% commission fee for every completed sale. They pay via PayPal and charge a payment processing fee of 2.5%+$0.30.

TCG Player is worth trying if you want to sell with a reputable site.

2. Card Market

Another place where you can sell Yugioh cards is Card Market. Like TCG Player, this platform allows you to sell various card games like Magic cards and Pokemon cards.

The process is quite simple. You only need to do the following:

  • Create a seller account
  • Indicate whether you’re selling individual cards or in bulk
  • Grade your cards according to the condition
  • Upload images of your Yugioh cards
  • Post your listing
  • Wait for buyers to contact you

Card Market charges a 5% fee on completed sales. They also charge a 3% currency conversion fee.

Your money is paid through PayPal or direct bank transfer. Card Market is an excellent option if you’re looking for something professional.

3. Troll and Toad

Troll and Toad is a popular marketplace for gaming collectibles like Pokemon cards, Yugioh cards, and Dragon Ball.

This platform buys the cards and then resells them. They have a buy list you can use to determine how much they’re willing to pay for your Yugioh cards.

After submitting your list, ship the items to Troal and Toad. Once they receive your package, they verify your items and deposit your payment.

Payment is made via PayPal, check, or website credit. Website credit orders over $30 receive a 25% bonus. Store credit is an excellent option if you intend to make future purchases on the platform.

Your order has to be at least $30 to be eligible for payment via check. If you opt for PayPal, you must pay the 2.9%+$0.30 payment processing fee.

4. Sell2BBNovelties 

Sell2BBNovelties is a prominent player in the trading card games market. It’s a great option to sell your Yugioh cards online. You can sell individual cards or in bulk.

You can use this platform to turn your Yugioh cards into cash in three simple steps:

  • Review what Sell2BBNovelties are buying and process your order
  • After your order is confirmed, ship your items
  • Get paid

They issue payments within a week of receiving the package. It’s done via PayPal or store credit.

If your order is above $30, you’re in luck because Sell2BBNovelties offers free shipping in this case.

The platform only purchases cards that are in good condition. It’s, therefore, not a great option if you want to get rid of overly used cards.

5. Dave and Adam’s

Dave and Adam’s is another reputable collectibles and trading card platform. They claim to be the world’s largest online seller of trading cards.

It’s a great site if you want to sell booster packs and boxes. You can also sell individual cards.

The first step to selling Yugioh cards at Dave and Adam’s is to check their buy list to determine the cards you can sell and their prices.

They pay you via check, PayPal, or store credit. You can avoid shipping fees if your order is above $199.

Dave and Adam’s is great if you want to sell Yugioh cards in bulk. You’ll earn more for bulk cards than individual cards.

6. Heart of the Cards

Heart of the Cards is an excellent platform if you have some Yugioh cards you’d like to sell.

Yugioh cards should meet the following requirements to sell on Heart of Cards:

  • They should be in near mint or slightly played condition
  • The cards shouldn’t be sleeved
  • The cards’ print should be in English

They’re picky about the condition of foiled cards since the damage is usually visible. They’re strict about Yugioh cards since most of them are foil cards. 

Heart of Cards is an excellent platform if you want an intermediary to sell your cards. It’s also excellent to grow your collection or learn more about Yugioh as you sell. 

However, you won’t make total market value for your collection because they also need to make a profit when they resell your cards.

Heart of Cards offers up to 40% of the current market value for your Yugioh cards. You can also earn up to 50% store credit, an excellent option if you plan to make future purchases from them.

7. Game Goblins

If you’re still looking for a place to sell your Yugioh cards online, try Game Goblins. This platform is similar to Dave and Adam’s. 

You must first check their buy list to determine what you’ll make for your cards. Advantageously, their buy list is on a Google Sheet, allowing you to swiftly look for the Yugioh cards you wish to sell based on their number and set. 

Game Goblins offers you up to 65% of the current market value of your Yugioh cards. You can also earn store credit, earning a 25% bonus.

They offer between $5 and $25 for most cards, but you may earn up to $100 if you have the rare ones. 

8. Core TCG

Another place to sell Yugioh cards is Core TCG. A huge perk of this platform is that they’re always buying. Therefore, you’re sure to change your Yugioh cards to cash anytime.

Check out their buy list to see what they’re buying. You can also contact them if you want to sell a card that’s not on their buy list.

They offer payment via PayPal, check, or store credit. They recommend the use of PayPal due to the delays associated with checks. You get a 20% bonus when you select store credit.

Ensure to check and adhere to the rules and regulations of Core TCG. Breaking any rules may lead to a 20% penalty.

9. eBay

eBay allows you to connect with millions of buyers worldwide and sell virtually anything. 

Since there’s a massive market for trading cards and collectibles, you can quickly sell your Yugioh cards on eBay.

All you have to do on this platform is:

  • Create a listing
  • Find a buyer and close the deal
  • Get paid

Add clear photos of the cards to your listing so buyers know what they’re buying. You’ll also set your price when you sell on eBay. 

You can search for similar cards to see what other sellers are charging. You can also use the sites like Yugioh Prices to determine the best competitive prices.

Your selling price should offset the seller fees and shipping costs. eBay charges a 10-15% seller fee for the final value of your cards. 

The first 250 monthly listings are free, after which you’ll be charged a $0.35 fee. You need not worry about this if you’re a one-time seller.

The massive size of the eBay market makes it one of the best places to sell Yugioh cards, especially if you’re selling in bulk.

10. Etsy

Are you still wondering where to sell Yugioh cards? Etsy is a great platform to consider.

You can sell your cards on Etsy in a few simple steps:

  • Create a seller account
  • List your cards
  • Get a buyer
  • Ship the cards
  • Get paid

Etsy charges you a $0.20 listing fee. They also charge a 6.5% transaction fee for every completed sale. They offer payment through PayPal.

You’ll have to cover shipping costs if you sell your cards on Etsy. Ensure you factor these costs into your selling price to avoid incurring losses.

11. Mercari 

Like eBay, Mercari is a reputable online marketplace that allows you to sell virtually anything. They allow you to list your cards for free.

One perk of Mercari is that they send you prepaid shipping labels up to 40% off retail carrier rates for standard and economy rates.

The Mercari fees are as follows: 

  • 10% seller fee for every completed sale
  • 2.9%+$0.50 payment processing fee

Sites like Mercari are worth considering if you’d like to quickly sell your Yugioh card collection online. Another perk is that you can still sell your cards even if they aren’t rare.

Extra Reading: How To Sell on Mercari Successfully 

12. OfferUp

OfferUp allows you to sell your Yugioh card collection to online or local buyers. Like Mercari, OfferUp enables you to sell almost anything. 

The popular items to sell on OfferUp include clothes, electronics, and sneakers. You can also get good deals on your Yugioh cards.

Listing your cards on this platform is free. Remember to add clear photos and a catchy description to your listing.

You don’t have to worry about getting ripped off by buyers because OfferUp has safe community meetup spots where you can meet with your buyer and complete the transaction.

OfferUp charges a 12.9% fee with a minimum fee of $1.99. This platform is a good option if you want to sell your cards locally to avoid shipping.

13. Facebook Marketplace

Another platform that allows you to sell your Yugioh card collection near you is the Facebook marketplace.

Sites like Facebook Marketplace have forums that consist of people with the same interests. If you can find a group of Yugioh enthusiasts, you’ll get good value for your cards.

Like any other marketplace, it’s important to add clear photos and honest descriptions so people know what they’re buying.

You’ll also need to find out how other sellers are pricing similar cards so that you set a reasonable price for yours. You should, however, leave some room for negotiation.

14. Pawn Shops

Selling Yugioh cards to pawn shops is an excellent option for quick cash. The advantage is that pawn shops offer money, and the process requires few formalities.

If you want to profit, sell to a pawnbroker with knowledge of Yugioh cards. However, a few pawn shops deal in trading cards. Here are the things pawn shops buy.

The biggest downside of selling to pawn shops is they offer a price below market value since they have to make a profit when they resell your cards.

Pawn shops are an excellent option if you’re only interested in getting rid of your cards regardless of the price.

You can find a local pawn shop near you by searching on the internet. Call ahead to find out if they deal in Yugioh cards. Ensure your cards are clean and in good condition to earn more.

Extra Reading: Surprising Things You Could Pawn

15. Local Card Shops

Consider selling your Yugioh cards to a local card shop for quick cash. These shops are easy to find. You only need to search on Google.

Most of these shops have in-house appraisers who evaluate your cards’ value before buying them. However, knowing the worth of your cards before going to the store is vital.

The downside is that these shops will only buy your cards if they’re in demand. You may not make much if your cards don’t fit that description.

Like pawn shops, local card shops don’t pay the total market value of items.

16. Comic Book Stores

Selling to comic book stores is better than selling to a pawn shop because the former is guaranteed to know the worth of Yugioh cards.

You still won’t get the exact amount your cards are worth, but at least you get to avoid shipping costs. Also, selling to comic book stores is faster than on online platforms.

Once you get a local comic book store near you, call ahead to confirm if they’re buying Yugioh cards.

17. Reddit r/YGOMarketplace

Reddit is one of the best places to sell Yugioh cards since you’re bound to find people who know about Yugioh cards and their worth. You may earn the total market value on this platform.

Reddit has various community spaces made up of people with similar interests. An example of such a space is r/YGOMarketplace.

This subreddit is home to over 23,000 Yugioh fans who sell and buy Yugioh cards amongst themselves.

There are several rules on the space that you have to follow to avoid getting kicked out. They also have a feedback system allowing buyers and sellers to give transaction feedback.

You can easily spot reputable buyers by reading feedback from sellers who’ve worked with them before. You can also land local buyers in this space.

Factors That Affect Yugioh Cards Prices

Once you’ve identified where to sell your Yugioh card collection, it’s essential to understand factors that impact the prices of the cards.

Understanding these factors is crucial to avoid overcharging your customers or getting ripped off.

Here are several factors that determine the prices of Yugioh cards:

Condition

Regarding state, cards are categorized from heavy play to near-mint. The more beaten your cards are, the lower your money. 

Ensure your cards are in good condition before you try to sell them.

Playability

The usefulness of your cards for play also affects their prices. Playability is affected by how powerful the card is in a metagame tournament. 

When a card is too powerful, it may get banned from tournaments, decreasing its value. Check the Yugioh ban list to determine if you have any banned cards.

Rarity

Rarity affects the availability of a card in the market, which in turn impacts its price. Yugioh cards are purchased in sets. One set is made up of nine common to rare cards.

In terms of rarity, Yugioh cards are classified into the following groups:

  • Common
  • Rare
  • Super Rare
  • Ultra Rare
  • Ultimate Rare
  • Secret Rare
  • Ghost Rare
  • Starfoil Rare
  • Mosaic Rare
  • Duelist League

You need to sort your cards according to rarity to determine how much you can make from selling them.

Edition

First and last editions are highly sought after since they’re more valuable than unlimited cards. They’re, therefore, more likely to earn more than cards in unlimited supply.

You can recognise the first and last edition cards by checking if there’s a gold security foil in the bottom right corner. It’ll have a silver foil if it’s an unlimited edition card.

Use the foiling to find out the worth of your Yugioh cards.

Tips for Selling Yugioh Cards Successfully

Now that you know how to determine the worth of your cards and where to sell them, here are a few tips for selling Yugioh cards successfully.

Keep these in mind as you sell your cards to maximize profit.

  • Grade your cards according to condition: Separate the good from damaged ones. Remove heavy play cards with creases, markings, and dog ears.
  • Organize cards by rarity: Group the good cards according to rarity. If you have many cards, organize them by set too.
  • Research card prices: Find out the current market price for each card. Use platforms like Yugioh Prices to search for specific card pricing.
  • Create an asking price list: Record your prices on an Excel spreadsheet. Instead of fixed prices, you can make a list with a range of prices to be flexible with your pricing. 
  • Select a selling option and sell: Choose a platform to sell your cards depending on whether you want to sell locally or online. Ensure you do a background check on a buyer or a platform before selling.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where Can I Get My Yugioh Cards Valued?

There are several websites you can use if you want to find out the market value of your Yugioh cards. One such platform is Yugioh Prices.

Yugioh Prices is a reputable platform that provides you with the following:

  • Accurate and realistic card prices
  • Information on price changes
  • Real booster pack values for every Yugioh set

The platform calculates card prices by checking what multiple card sellers offer.

Another place to get your Yugioh cards valued is at a pawn shop. Some pawn shops have in-store evaluators who assess the worth of your cards.

Can You Sell Yugioh Cards at Gamestop?

Gamestop deals in several trading card games, including Yugioh. If you have a Yugioh card collection you want to get rid of, consider selling them to Gamestop. 

Your cards must be in good condition to sell to Gamestop. You can change your Yugioh cards to cash in a few simple steps:

  • Find the values of the cards
  • Visit a GameStop store
  • Choose a payment method

Are Yugioh Cards Worth Selling?

Yes, Yugioh cards are worth selling. If you have a Yugioh card collection you no longer use, you can sell it to make extra cash. 

First and limited editions are valuable, but you can still earn a good sum from selling common cards.

You can earn the full market value of your cards if they’re in good condition. Whether you want to sell online or locally, you can try plenty of platforms.

You can sell your Yugioh cards on the following platforms:

  • TCG Player
  • Game Goblins
  • eBay
  • Heart of the Cards
  • Mercari

You can also sell your cards to local pawn shops or comic book stores near you. However, these won’t give you the full value of your cards because they have to make a profit when reselling them.

The advantage of pawn shops and comic book stores is that they give you instant cash. They’re great options to make quick cash for an emergency.

Yugioh cards are worth selling. They have a massive loyal fan base that is always buying the cards. You’ll likely make a good amount if you have the right cards.

Where Is the Best Place To Sell Yugioh Cards?

The best place to sell Yugioh cards is to a direct seller. This way, you avoid the costs associated with intermediaries.

eBay and TCG Player are the most popular places to sell Yugioh cards. The process is slow, but they’re excellent options if you don’t want to meet with the buyer.

It‘s wise to compare all platforms before settling on one to determine the one that works best for you.

Final Thoughts

Selling Yugioh cards may sometimes be tedious, but worth it in the long run. You can sell Yugioh cards as a side hustle or a full-time venture.

Selling Yugioh cards is a great way to make money online and locally.  You should make a good amount if you’re willing to put in the work of looking for valuable cards.

I hope this list helps you determine where and how to sell your cards for the most profit. 

Looking for other places to sell your collectibles? Checkout:

Lydia is a personal finance expert and the founder of Sproutinue, a personal finance site helping you find legit ways to make money, save money, and achieve financial freedom. She has been featured on various major financial publications, including Investopedia, Business Insider, GoBankingRates, and more.

Back To Top