Skip to content

Where To Sell Pokemon Cards for Cash in 2024 (11 Best Places)

Where to Sell Pokemon Cards

This post may contain affiliate links which means that may make a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only promote products that we love and feel will benefit our readers. Please read our Disclosure Policy for more information.

Selling collectibles is one of the easiest ways to make a little extra money. Finding buyers for childhood toys and other vintage items is relatively easy because of the nostalgia associated with them. For one, you can opt to sell Pokémon cards, enabling you to earn money and declutter simultaneously.

If you still have the original Pokémon cards, you probably have a pot of gold. Still, selling the newer editions will make you money as well. The secret to making good money selling Pokémon cards to collectors and fans is to know the best places to sell them. 

Once you know where to sell Pokemon cards and other Pokémon merch, research to determine the value of your collection to avoid getting shortchanged.

Where to Sell Pokémon Cards Online

Selling Pokémon cards online is the most convenient option because it takes little effort. There are several digital sites where you can list your Pokémon cards, and more are cropping up daily. Some of these sites are more trustworthy than others, and some pay more. Shop around and compare the selling prices to make the most of your collection.

The following are some of the best places to sell your Pokémon cards:

1. eBay

eBay is arguably the most popular digital marketplace, frequented by millions every day. Buyers love it because they can buy affordable items, and sellers like the platform because they get to set the price. You can sell your Pokemon cards in bulk on eBay.

When listing your cards, you can set a fixed price or put them up for auction, where the buyers can bid for the items. Potential buyers can also submit their offers if you’re open to haggling. It’s advisable to look at how other sellers are pricing their merch to get a rough idea of how to price yours.

You can also use a card pricing guide to help you set reasonable card prices. If you have rare cards, you can get professional grading that the buyers will trust. This way, the cards will sell much faster.

Remember to be descriptive when listing the cards. Provide your potential buyers with all the information they might need. Also, be careful when packaging the cards to avoid shipping accidents and potential disputes. eBay allows you to pay shipping costs, which can be up to the buyer.

2. Cape Fear Games

Cape Fear Games is a website dedicated to games, mainly board games, Pokémon, and others. Cape Fear Games buys your Pokémon collection from you and lists them for sale. You can ship your collection to them or hand-deliver it and be paid instantly.

You can check Cape Fear Games’ buylist to see what they’re currently looking for — single cards or bulk cards. On the seller’s page, you’ll see what you can expect to get for your card, depending on its grade and condition.

If you’re going to ship your collection, you have to wait for an acceptance email before shipping it. Your shipment must get to Cape Fear Games within a week to qualify for payment. You can expect to be paid via check, PayPal, or store credit.

3. Troll and Toad

Troll and Toad is a digital marketplace where you can sell your Pokémon singles and lots. They require you to send the collection first, and you’ll receive the payment within five days of their last inspection.

To be eligible to sell your Pokémon collection on Troll and Toad, it must be worth at least $30 to get direct payment. If your order is less than $30, you get store credit instead.

A great way to make the most of your Pokémon cards on Troll and Toad is to create a buylist. Browse the Pokémon series and then enter your items to determine the current buyback price.

Troll and Toad is an excellent option when finding where to sell your Pokémon cards if your lot is worth more than $30. In addition to the money, sellers generally get a 35% bonus on shipping. Sellers pay the shipping costs, and the items must be received within seven days.

Learn More: Where to sell Disney VHS Tapes

4. TCGPlayer Marketplace

This is an online marketplace that facilitates the trading of card games, including Pokémon. It’s a great option to list your cards because you can easily reach Pokémon gamers and collectors, your primary target audience. Collectors are known to pay good money for collectibles, so you stand to earn higher prices on TCGPlayer.

You can create a free account on the site, but once you make a sale, you have to pay seller fees, depending on the seller type. The maximum seller fee is 10.25% of the sale price and an additional 3% PayPal fee. 

Frequent sellers can upgrade their seller type to Pro seller, where they’re eligible for reduced fees. With TCGPlayer, you can sell your cards within and outside the country, which expands your selling opportunities.

5. Dave and Adam’s

Dave and Adam’s is another site specializing in cards, including sports cards and Pokémon cards. To sell to Dave and Adam’s, you first have to call their corporate office and give them your lot details. If your cards do not make the cut, they’re shipped back to you for free.

Aside from the mail-in options, Dave and Adam’s offer a pickup collection. If you opt for the pickup, you get 95% of the price. It is still an excellent option for people who don’t want to mail their cards in.

Extra Reading: Things You Didn’t Know You Could Pawn

6. CCG Castle

CCG Castle buys various card game series. You can look through the buylist on their site for the items you’re looking to sell. The store also has a catalog, where you can see the buyback price. 

To sell your items, click on the “Sell us Yours” button, and then add the items to your cart. Their product listing has details about the number of cards they want to buy for a particular item.

Sellers pay the shipping fees on CCG Castle. Their payment options include PayPal and store credit. CCG Castle also has a rewards program where you can earn digital coins whenever you purchase items from the site.

7. Card Cavern

If you’re looking for where to sell Pokemon cards for a lot of money, check out Card Cavern. They purchase more than $200 in cards from sellers every day. If your collection is worth more than $250, you must get special permission from the site or send it in multiple shipments. If you’re mailing single cards, you’re eligible for shipping credit up to $12.

As a seller, you can use Pokellector or other mobile apps to generate a Pokémon Trading Card Game Online (PTGO) code, which will give you an accurate estimate.

8. Mercari

Mercari is a digital marketplace where you can sell vintage items, including your Pokémon collection. The advantage of Mercari is that you can sell your cards internationally, which can fetch higher prices.

Apps like Mercari are popular for Pokémon sellers because they have millions of users and offer secure payment.

Extra Reading: Best Items to Sell on Mercari

9. Social Media

You can also choose to sell your Pokémon collection on social media platforms like Instagram or Twitter. You can reach a wide audience with social media, and you get to determine your prices. To reach your target audience, join Pokémon fan groups and use hashtags to increase the visibility of your posts.

Where to Sell Pokémon Cards Near Me

You can still sell your Pokémon cards locally if you’re not a big fan of digital marketplaces. If you’ve been thinking, “What is the best place to sell Pokémon cards near me?” consider the following options:

10. Local Comic Shops

Check your local comic shop to see if they buy Pokémon cards. It is easier and more convenient to sell to a local store because you won’t have to think about finding buyers or worry about shipping and seller fees.

Comic shops specialize in trading card games and other accessories, so they pay more than pawn shops. Contact your local comic shop and ask whether they’re looking to buy Pokemon cards, how much they’re willing to pay for each card, and what payment options they have. This way, you can decide whether the trip to the store is worth it or if you’re better off finding other platforms.

Comic stores typically pay in cash or store credit, but you shouldn’t expect to make as much as you would selling the cards online. The store is looking to make a profit, so they buy the cards from you at a trade-in value.

11. Facebook Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace is a popular selling option, given the number of people you’ll reach on the platform. The first requirement for selling on the site is a Facebook account. You can list your Pokémon cards or other items on Facebook Marketplace for free. 

Additionally, sellers are not required to pay any seller fees when they make sales.

Once you’ve listed your items, buyers can contact you on the platform. To price your items competitively, check how other sellers are pricing their Pokémon cards. 

Buyers typically pay in cash or use a debit card. You have to schedule a pickup time and location with your buyer.

Tips for Selling Pokémon Cards for Cash

You want to make the most out of your Pokémon collection, which is why you must put in the work to maximize your profit. First, you must know the cards’ value and package them carefully to avoid damage. 

Here are some tips to help you make the most cash from your Pokémon cards.

Find Rare Pokémon cards

Some Pokémon cards are worth more than others because they have special symbols and other unique features. Here’s how you tell if a Pokémon card is rare:

  • Holofoil
  • Secret numbers
  • Rare letters
  • Rarity symbols (stars and diamonds)
  • Tournament and convention Pokemon cards

Organize your collection

There are approximately 70 sets of Pokemon cards in the United States, spanning over 20 years. Organizing your cards by set and numerical order is advisable, so your potential buyers can easily inspect them. 

You can use sites and apps like Pokellector to build a checklist so you can see what cards are missing from your collection.

Grade your Pokémon Cards

Before selling your Pokémonn cards, it is vital to have them graded accurately. This is especially helpful when mailing the cards to vendors who might reject them. A widely used scale is the PSA grading system, which is a 10-point scale, with 10 being the highest value. 

You can grade the cards yourself, but it’s better to have them professionally graded by a PSA-certified grader.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you Sell Pokémon Cards at Gamestop?

GameStop sells Pokémon cards online, but they do not buy Pokémon cards. GameStop restocks the Pokémon cards, so they don’t have an external party dealing with the restocking. 

Most of what they sell comes from their own central warehouse. It’s hard to tell who supplies the GameStop warehouse, but they’re more interested in larger wholesalers than individual sellers.

Is it Worth Selling My Pokémon Cards?

Some sellers have made hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars from their Pokémon cards, so selling your cards is worth it. Remember that not all Pokémon cards will make you that amount of money, but if you have unique cards, you can earn good money even on a single exchange.

The amount you make from selling your Pokémon cards will depend on their condition, whether they’re special or regular, and the platform on which you sell them. Doing research will help you make informed decisions so you can make the most of your Pokémon collection.

Final Thoughts

Selling your Pokémon cards is an easy side hustle that can earn you hundreds of dollars. Now that you know where to sell Pokemon cards, you can decide if you’d rather sell them online or in person. Whichever route you choose, follow basic safety regulations to avoid being scammed.

The Pokémon craze has been around for a while, and if you have rare Pokémon cards, you might be sitting on a gold mine. The best way to make the most of your Pokémon cards is to have them professionally valued. Selling Pokémon cards shouldn’t be a hassle, provided you take all the necessary steps and make informed decisions.

Looking for other ways to make money from your collectibles? Checkout:

Lydia is a personal finance expert and the founder of Sproutinue, a personal finance site helping you find legit ways to make money, save money, and achieve financial freedom. She has been featured on various major financial publications, including Investopedia, Business Insider, GoBankingRates, and more.

Back To Top